A Toronto Psychogeography Society Blog



Home » Archives » December 2004 » Windsor Report: Citybreaking

[Previous entry: "Cold"] [Next entry: "Windsor Report II: City Remembered"]

12/29/2004: "Windsor Report: Citybreaking"

I’m in Windsor for Christmas. I drive a lot when I’m here. It’s the only way around. You can drive, then park, then walk a bit, then get back in the car. I wanted to go read at my old university library, but it was closed for the week. I had to resort to the Starbucks downtown, a relatively new outlet on Ouellette Avenue, the main strip. It’s also the place that most reminds me of Toronto. Starbucks-like atmospheres are ubiquitous in Toronto, but in Windsor they’re hard to come by. Watching yourself slide into a self-hating Starbucks person is no fun, but it seemed safe and familiar.

I sat in the window. I could see the downtown theatre complex from my seat. It closed for a few years – Windsor people could only see movies at the mall or out at the Silvercity on Walker Road - out by the Costco, out by the PetSmart, out by the 401, out by the Windsor Christian Fellowship (God even comes in big-box format now). My mom says when you drive down Walker Road, you don’t feel like you’re in Windsor.

I walked down Ouellette north, towards the river. I forgot how many abandoned buildings there are. I think when you live with something everyday, you ignore the sore spots. It’s like living with a bad knee - people just sort of work around it and ignore it in order to get along. The Bank of Montreal is still in a fairly nice old 1960s building. I think this is where the biggest ever bank heist in Canadian history happened, somewhere around 1971. The thieves got away with more than $1 million in cash - money that had just come in from the Windsor Raceway (harness racing). Maybe these details are wrong. It doesn’t matter though – when the Windsor Star ran a retrospective of the event, it made it seem like this event was Windsor’s coming of age in a mythic sense. All the danger and badassness was romanced away.

I walked down to the river to look at Detroit. It was from this vantage point that me and Dreadlock Melissa watched Detroit’s Hudson Building implode in the late 1990s. The building was so solid we could feel the ground shake even on our side of the river. One recent edition to the skyline is the GM logo they slapped onto the Renaissance Centre. It ruins the clean lines of the John Portman glass tube (the same glass tube makes up the Peachtree Centre in Atlanta). It’s looks crappy now. As crappy as the new BMO logo on First Canadian Place in Toronto. There are many reasons why I’ll never buy a GM car, but my official line is that it’s because of their careless use of their logo.

Dieppe Gardens stretches along the riverfront . We used to watch the annual Detroit-Windsor fireworks display from the ”Welcome Centre”, built in 1957. Windsor was on the move in 1957. The city used good fonts (contrast it with the horrible sign underneath the original “Welcome”) and things were built, well, with some sense of style (contrast the Welcome Centre with the crappy blue and white casino tower rising in the background). Windsor was all about full employment, a real, functioning downtown, and people from Newfoundland and Nova Scotia (the great Canadian migration) moving here to work at Ford or GM or Chrysler or Hiram Walker. My dad’s family made the move from Malta (the great European migration) in 1964, and my Nannu got a job at the Chrysler assembly plant. When I was a kid, Windsor seemed so civilized and urbane and right and good. I was always excited to go downtown. I try and imagine it without being nostalgic, trying to appreciate the things that are there now, but it’s difficult. Even the public washrooms are closed. I hate it when conveniences like these are closed. It’s like the city became a deadbeat parent, though they do provide a sign indicating where the nearest operating washrooms are. I think some of them are far away. Hopefully nobody has to go very badly, but I suppose it’s assumed everybody has a car.

In honour of Chrysler’s importance to Windsor development as fine and good place, the city expropriated an entire downtown block (the only remaining 19th Century block in the city), a block full of independent businesses (places like: The Spotted Dog where the Windsor art bands played; the Windsor Press Club where you could push a doorbell on the bar that made an “applause” sign light up above the bottles; 13 Below, a bar owned in part by Ritchie Hawtin where you could hear the best DJs play, for free) – including the last and best of Windsor’s bookstores, South Shore Books (the “Pages Books” of Windsor) where I bought my first Camus and my first Gabriel Garcia Marquez. In place of all this the city allowed developers to build the Daimler Chrysler Building. Today it sits, half empty, 4 years later. There is no life there, not at 1am or 2pm, and you can see right through the building and out the other side. It’s like they salted the Earth and nothing will grow here. Next door to the Chrysler Building is the CIBC Building, where my dad was made a Canadian citizen in 1980. There is an identical CIBC building in Halifax, and it looks a lot like the ugly Toronto Star building. Same era I think, late 60s early 70s. Maybe the same sad architect.

There is a neat stone monument called Pray for Peace in the park. It was a centennial project, put up in 1967. When I was a kid I would climb up on the globe and pick out Windsor, Nova Scotia and Malta. Malta was hard because it wasn’t marked, so I sort of felt around underneath Sicily and guessed where it was. On occasion someone has defaced the faces with lipstick or whatever, but they’ve remained remarkably unscathed generally. Maybe people like peace, even the punks.

Not far away is the new Art Gallery of Windsor (AGW). It’s on the site of the temporary casino that opened in the mid 90s. The gallery was there, and then relocated to the mall so the casino could set up shop while their permanent thing could be built on the eastside of the downtown. During the new gallery’s construction in 2000, I saw a bunch of people get pepper sprayed and tear gassed by RCMP officers during the Organization of American States conference. It was the first time I experienced crowd control chemicals. Our eyes watered and throats hurt, and I was standing well away from the people who the RCMP were after. Nothing so festive now, just passing cars and empty space. The gallery building stands by itself, surrounded by empty lots to the West, South and South East. Next door to the gallery, directly east, there is a overgrown pit, meant for a condo development. I think this was started in like 1984. The hoarding is even falling apart. It’s funny how this image is the same as the images of Detroit in the 70s and 80s, where they would show the new Detroit rising above the old broken, burnt, and beaten down one (the Phoenix rises, that sort of thing). All the empty fields around the gallery used to be a dense commercial and residential neighbourhood. This area was also expropriated by the city in the late 80s for a proposed multiuse arena and convention centre that never materialized. We lost a part of the city. I remember reading article after article at the time about all the good that would come of this. When the temporary casino was there they turned it all into a vast array of parking lots, which now are largely empty and unsued – the casino is too far to the east, and casino patrons don’t like to walk. They did put up basketball nets in one of the lots though. That is nice.

Even this great old designated heritage building is empty. The space in front of it used to be a Canadian Tire. It used to have a cute restaurant in the basement. Windsor was full of this good stuff when I was kid. It was fine place, full of good buildings like the YMCA and good signage like at Lazares Furs. Now we’ve been left with parking lots and empty buildings and vulgar displays of shitty cool in the form of dancing hot peppers. Peppers Bar is a particular contrast with my old Windsor. On weekends, if you walk by the lineup waiting to get in the place, you can be certain you’ll be verbally accosted by the Abercrombie and Fitch date rape mob lined up out front. They come from Michigan, mostly for the lower drinking age, but maybe they stay for the wet t-shirt contests. This used to the Windsor Birks store, where blue haired ladies took home their blue boxes filled with blue tissue paper that held jewelry or whatever it is they were into. I don’t know where the blue haired ladies go now. Maybe they get rides out to the Costco.

I did go into the AGW yesterday, since I was walking by, and I was sort of cold and needed to warm up. I was surprised to find they have selection of Edward Burtynsky’s “Manufactured Landscapes” collection there, the one that was at the AGO in Toronto this past year. In contrast to the AGO’s packed and hot rooms, I was the only person in the AGW apart from the security guards. It made the pictures more sad and horrible and stark because there was nobody next to me to react to, or react for, or to share in my awe. The selections were mostly his Shipbreaking photos. Burtynsky took pictures of old ocean going vessels that had been dragged up onto the mudflats of Chittagong, Bangladesh, where they were systematically dismantled. Massive pieces of the ships are missing in the some of the photos. They seem mortally wounded and torn apart, but enough of the ship is still there so you can tell it was seaworthy at one time. The pictures reminded me a bit too much, and perhaps a bit too obviously, of what they’ve done to Windsor.



Replies: 12 Comments

on Sunday, January 2nd, MK said

Nicely written, S. I have never visited Windsor, but after reading this entry feel that I have a good understanding of its narrative arc.

on Monday, January 10th, dylan said

It boggles my mind - and enrages me - that within the last twenty years cities were STILL destroying effective and lively blocks and neighbourhoods in order to put up sterile, dead, futile megaprojects.

Did no one object? Did no one point out the consistent failure of such projects and how they kill a city?

on Tuesday, January 11th, j.w.a.p. said

dylan,
you're talking about a city council that moved the art gallery out to the mall to make a home for a temporary casino - these are not the most enlightened folks. as an entity, the city of Windsor has very little regard for it's own history, AND, being across the river from Detroit, has a bit of an inferiority complex that they attempt to deal with by seeming "progressive" and by appearing to "look to the future". they have no time for the past.
Windsor is essentially a small town masquerading as a big city, and it has a tendency to try to act like they think a big city should.
i have great memories of growing up in Windsor, and i wouldn't trade it for anything - but when i go back now, there is nothing i feel attached to anymore. if my parents didn't still live there, i can't imagine why i would ever go back.

on Wednesday, January 12th, pete pelisek said

a large portion of the folks in windsor didn't agree with the whole norwich block thing (myself included- i thought it was shortsighted and criminal against what makes smaller cities in ontario unique). i think it's a mistake to lump everyone together and depict the whole city as a gaggle of bourgeois idiots. the city council, the windsor star and chrysler combined their resources to ensure that the downtown was a universally bland concrete mound of shit, despite what anyone else really wanted. sure, a lot of the people in windsor don't want to think of a different world outside of their fucking dodge boys dakota S10 truck driving beer chugging going to the mall lives but that isn't true of the whole city. there's a rich cross section of people in windsor (and yes, there are actually people that consider themselves artists there), just as there is in any mid sized ontario town. the crimes against culture in windsor can happen just about anywhere and do. do you really think maple leaf gardens is going to preserved in all its' glory? it'll probably be turned into maple leaf condos (for the vanilla white)and if we're lucky it'll have a fucking mall attached or market or whatever that no one will go to anyway.

on Thursday, January 13th, Shawn said

I'd go to the Whole Foods if they opened it.

Pete is right though. j.w.a.p.> I don't know if i agree with all your sentiments about windsor. it isn't a city of rubes. if i had no more connections there, i'd still go back. i is a rather unique place - a mid sized border city. interesting things happen.

dylan> there were lots who saw the folly. a group of artists even painted a broken yellow line around that block before it was torn down, complete with sissors as in "cut here and remove". it made a lot of people sad.

on Friday, January 14th, j.w.a.p. said

apparently, i had a lot more people calling me a fag, or punching me in the mouth because i wore orange Converse, than either of you did. there are plenty of closed minded rubes in that city - maybe the majority of them just went to my school.
and i know that there are plenty of open-minded people in windsor as well. there was a surprisingly large art community when i was living there. the only reason i stopped getting into fights was because i managed to surround myself with a large majority of them. they're what made the last 7 or 8 years of my life there bearable.
but my comments were directed at 'the city', not at the individual people that live there.

on Friday, January 14th, Shawn said

Toronto is a huge place though - you can surround, and insulate, yourself with whatever community you want - and there is a sense of safety in that community. That's why the downtown is crawling with the homosexuals. But there are certainly kids getting gas-pedelled and beaten up throughout this city as well. Living in Toronto at 30 can't be compared to living in Windsor at 15 or 12.

on Friday, January 14th, Anna said

I have no parents or old friends or alma maters in Windsor, but I go there all the time as a tourist and enthusiast. I love it. I cry about the dereliction and regressive "progress", but somehow it seems like the Windsor that has been knocked down or built over still haunts or looms or something, so you don't have the same sense of loss that you have in, say, London.

Windsor doesn't feel like a small town in a big city costume to me, so much. It feels like a firm, solid, monumental city, an ur-city, a city with more citiness sometimes than Toronto even. I romanticize it to the point that I lose all credibility, but there is something very organic-seeming and genuine about the citiness of Windsor. It has to do with the symbiosis of greasy-handed, assembly-line, Ford/Chrysler blues and latch-key-kid-in-a-bored-city arts and culture. Windsor has big industry that follows the metaphor of the coal mine: the dads of everyone go underground, eventually, to the casino or the Hiram Walkers or the plant, but it also has a university with an MFA program. Take that, London!

If I could give a billion dollars to anywhere I’d give it to Windsor. They could resurrect Room Magazine and get someone good to do the layout. They could still mirror the sexy body of Detroit but wouldn’t have to feel like the runner-up to a place that is 90% dilapidated. Maybe I’d give some money to Indonesia too.

on Sunday, January 16th, j.w.a.p. said

bah.
i don't know how to go back and erase entries once they've been posted here, but if i could, i think i would.
apparently i've been feeling just a wee bit ""grrrr" this past week, and my argumentative skills quickly devolved over the course of this discussion, to the point of "Thag no like city!"
like most people i'm sure, i have a strong love/hate relationship with my hometown. 90% of the time i love Windsor, and i'm proud as hell to have grown up there. but somedays - last week, for example - i don't like it so much.
it happens.

but while i might love the city, it still makes me angry most of the time, and most of that has to do with it's lack of respect for history (and in this i am not talking about the average Joe or Jane Windsor, but the city council, or the city itself as a larger institution). half of the time, when i drive around and think of all of the "things that used to be", it makes me weep. or at the very least, give off a very stern "tsk-tsk".
realizing that they tore down my first grade school (from K to Grade 4) a couple of years ago to put up condos or some shit, made me feel sad. and tired.
and seeing the Norwich block (which Shawn spoke of) nowadays just completely breaks my heart.
but then again, sometimes when i go back to the city, i like to enter it the long way around (my parents live on the eastern edge of the city), coming off of the end of the 401 and driving out to the western edge of the city before turning around and meandering back to my parents' house. and my heart does swell, just a little bit.

so yes, i may love windsor, but i don't think i will ever be IN love with it, ever again.

on Monday, April 18th, kostenlose online casinos said

Very nice site. Keep up the good work.

kostenlose online casinos

on Monday, April 18th, casinos en ligne said

Great site! I'm into it time after time and it's been extremely productive.

casinos en ligne

on Friday, April 22nd, Casino in linea said

congrats mate! Fine job and fine site!

Casino in linea

All that can be found anywhere can be found in Toronto.
-Victor Hugo, with some liberty and paraphrase.

headshot (14k image)

blog home
blog archives
TorPsyGeo Society home

Links We like:
[murmur]
Spacing
Toronto Public Space Committee
Nothingness

Blogs We like:
MK
Matt B Images
me, my life + infrastructure
purselipsquarejaw
Glowlab
Bert Archer's Blog

Search the archives:

Syndicate:
XML
Kinja
Bloglines